Are we the problem – constantly looking for improvements in health, housing, education, care, transport?
Author: David Zigmond
Andy Burnham’s almost seamless coronation to Prime Minister seems to many – for now – bolstered by an upbeat fresh face, voice and energy. These recruit, though, a rather more seasoned requisite quintet of slogans: Change! Growth! Stability! Decisive fixing! (but) No more taxes!
Our last decade’s six prime ministers and their governments have all declaimed these shibboleths: they then all rapidly failed with their own styles and garnered accusations. Are all these carouselled premiers incompetent, or are their slogans now – at least attempted all together – unviable and undeliverable? How do slogans become shibboleths – essential utterances in order to proceed?
Behind these questions is an inconvenient truth we mostly avoid and evade: our societies – us! – we habitually expect much more but do not wish to pay commensurately.
We expect ceaseless improvements in health, housing, education, care, criminal justice, prisons, boundary control, national security, roads, travel, essential utilities … and now – loomingly – environmental hazard.
For several decades following World War 2 these expectations were deliverable: all these things did improve. Successive generations had greater wealth, ease, possibilities and longevity than their parents. These were due to advances in technology, mass production and distribution and then more democratic politics.
But these erstwhile blessings have increasingly become stymied: for example, our technology has increased our longevity at the price of much more expensive medical and social care; our technology has rocketed our consumerism and travel with increasingly depleting, destructive and polluting demands for energy and geophysical resources; our now unconstrained appetites lead to new health problems of obesity, polymorphous addictions and impulses; previously economically subject nations are now more-then-equal competitors in a world market.
To add to these accreted refractory problems we have added digitalisation to speed up and expedite responses, answers, products and deliveries. This has mostly subtracted from our tolerance of delay, complexity, ambiguous uncertainly. We want it all and we want it now! No: we don’t want to wait and understand instead. Hence the growing danger of specious populism in democratic politics.
I saw how much of this played out in my many decades working as an NHS doctor. The technology produced massive advances in health benefits and so the inevitable demand and its expenses. Over the years funding has increased sporadically but not commensurately. Successive governments for four decades have attempted instead to serially reform the service – to command, bribe, threaten or chivvy to get more for less – rather than getting us all to pay more for the blessings of our longer, healthier lives. The result of this side-stepping is a restively dissatisfied service: the patients are unhappy, the staff are unhappy and the back-footed managers struggle to manage.
Healthcare is a prominent, but one among many, example of our avoidance of contemporary society’s choice – our inescapable and inconvenient truth. A decade ago a Cabinet Minister said to me: “Most of us politicians know what’s necessary in the longer term. The problem is to even begin to say it and then get re-elected.”
As Russel B Long, long-serving U.S. Senator from Louisiana and former chairman of the Senate Finance Committee famously said:
“Don’t tax you, don’t tax me, tax that fellow behind the tree”
Many articles exploring similar themes are available on David Zigmond’s website: http://www.davidzigmond.org.uk/david-zigmond-archive-homepage/
The publisher is Citizen Network. Voting for a Change of Electorate © David Zigmond 2026.
community, politics, Sustainability, England, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Article