What can the public do as the UK Government pursues Gene Editing?
Author: Alicia Hull
The global scientists at the Doomsday Clock have, for the first time, listed climate change and the neoliberal pursuit of fossil-fuelled growth that drives it, as well as Modern Invasive science and AI, as serious risks to life on Earth.
Now we have to accept the fact that government policies are among the greatest dangers we face – when we are at the most dangerous position we have ever been - only 85 seconds to midnight.
Yet despite this analysis, new gene-edited bananas, followed closely by gene-edited tomatoes, are one of the latest projects supported by government investment.
Gene editing is one of the most dangerous invasive sciences. Intensive farming using chemical fertilisers and pesticides also drives climate change, loss of biodiversity and degradation of the soil. But it can be reversed by regenerative and organic farming. However, the unknown dangers of gene editing are worse, as we have no means of tracking them or reversing them once they are in the wild.
If approved by the Food Standards Agency (FSA), these bananas will make profits for a private company, Tropic, although the research has been paid for by the taxpayer.
The argument given for them is that they will save waste. It relies on the dubious claim that the public throw away bananas once they stop being yellow, so it assumes an ignorant public. Yet all this investment only brings ‘an extra day or two’ of freshness.
Gene editing and modification have a dismal history of failure. Crops claimed to change the world for the better are silently dropped. Gene-edited bananas are just another example of the stupidity, greed and tactics used. It diverts attention from the obvious, cheap solutions that people need to stop buying too many bananas at one time, and realise that spotty or even black bananas are perfectly fit to eat. They may be even better than fresher ones.
The public have always been against genetic modification. It is a gut reaction. Many will choose not to buy them. The government knows this but is committed to supporting new science and big corporations.
But research shows that genes still produce unexpected and unpredictable results with unintended consequences. Also, we now know that other parts of the DNA control development, and that plants and animals respond to their environment to develop in very different ways. The genetic code of a plant or animal is not the same as the resulting organism. This makes a mockery of claims that gene-editing produces organisms no different to normal breeding techniques.
Using these false claims, the government insisted that labelling was not necessary, knowing it would severely limit sales. The whole point of the Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Act 2023 was to stop the public from knowing which crops in their shops and restaurants were genetically modified so they could not choose what to eat.
It may seem a contradiction to trust the scientists who inform the Doomsday Clock, yet not trust the scientists promoting GM. Our whole worldview is dominated by the insights and progress of scientists. They are at the forefront of our knowledge and have enabled many extraordinary achievements.
Unfortunately, the history of lies from scientists involved in the production of tobacco or oil or any harmful substance has shown that they are as likely to lie as the businesses or politicians involved when their incomes are at stake. The brave and honourable ones are the whistleblowers.
Scientists involved in gene editing, when supported by governments, completely cut off from nature, seem to have forgotten the learning of centuries that produced farming methods for healthy food which also maintained a stable climate, biodiversity and healthy soils.
Their arrogance is such that ‘progress’ means innovation. Most alarmingly, they have moved from a philosophy of preserving nature to an assumption they can improve it.
Against this and many other documented dangers, only a united public can save our natural world and society, if we choose to use it. As we fund and run the country, no government could stand against a united public.
The publisher is Citizen Network. Is Gene Editing too Risky © Alicia Hull 2026.
Community Health, health & healthcare, nature & economics, Sustainability, England, Europe, Global, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Article