Living Loss

When relationships and community are relegated to an afterthought care gets lost.

Can Neighbours Care?

Author: Thomas Allan

Helder Jose Lopez fixed bikes in his London flat, a trade that ran alongside his battle with addiction. According to Luke Tanner, his neighbour, he was “much better at taking care of bikes than he was at taking care of himself.” When he died at home, it was over a week before Luke found him.

Luke hung Helder’s bike-repair sign back on the fence, this time with the words “R.I.P.” on it, then stayed there. Neighbours and other locals slowly gathered, people who had brought bikes, lent money, or offered lifts.

“We were because he was,” Luke reflected. Neighbours had done what they could in return for Helder’s cheap repairs. Perhaps they hoped that if he kept busy, he could find a way through his troubles. Kind as they were, small gifts and favours aren’t the same as really knowing someone. How can you be surrounded by people and die unseen?

Some of the neighbours questioned their right to care. One admitted she’d held back as it would be “meddling.” Others said that because they were not family or a close friend, stepping in would be an intrusion. Only after Helder died did some neighbours grasp the full extent of his need, by which time there was little anyone could do about it.

Prevention

I never met Helder, but the image of him lying there while the world outside his door went about its business is unsettling. Only recently a neighbour of mine was taken to hospital after an overdose. I’d recognised the signs myself, but didn’t feel able to help. Perhaps, like Helder’s neighbours, I only ever saw fragments of her struggles, enough to notice but not to step in.

Is there someone like Helder living in your neighbourhood? 

Rarely does crisis come out of nowhere. Loss — of roles, identity, people or routines — begins to accumulate long before. If loss is a condition of life rather than an event, as I believe it is, then grief is as much about living with loss as it is about dealing with the aftermath of death.

Whether Helder was ever seen by adult social care, I don’t know. People living in social isolation often fall off the radar completely. Those who are seen can be assessed as ‘independent’ or ‘ineligible’ despite barely scraping by, or they refuse help out of pride or fear.

When I think of Helder, I wonder whether prevention misses something important. The most effective form of prevention starts with people. Online forms and virtual assessments are useful, but they don’t create relationships. Without people in situ, signs of drift, grief, loneliness, and self-neglect easily get overlooked.

For Helder, prevention could have been simple. Beneath the broken bikes and the borrowed money was a man struggling to be seen. It could have been another human being there earlier, willing to stay for a while, who recognised what he was going through.

Derek, as I’ll call him, is a composite of men I’ve visited over twenty years in care. He was in his seventies and spent his working life as a haulier. He lived alone above a betting shop. His referral form said he was refusing support, hoarding and self-neglecting. Many professionals and care agencies had already tried to gain access to his flat to help him, but had been told where to go.

On my first visit I decided not to carry forms or lead with process-related questions. I knew he had driven nights for forty years, so I asked him about the roads. He told me about foggy motorways, interesting encounters, all-night cafes that had closed, and the freedom of using his cab as a second home.
After a while he opened up properly and told me how he wished he’d spent more time with his family, who were now lost to him. As well as providing him with a livelihood, his working life on the roads was itself a distraction from earlier losses, such as being sent to boarding school at the age of five and the death of a sibling in his teenage years.

His flat was an absolute mess, and his leg looked chronically bad, but that wasn’t the reason he stopped answering his door. He told me that people who knocked weren’t really interested in him. “Busybodies. Just tickin’ boxes, they is,” he said. It was hard to argue with him.

Listening to Derek talk for an hour did not solve his problems. But it did help restore some trust. At the outset, I didn’t need a specialist intervention. I needed some curiosity, a little bit of compassion, and some time.

Upstream

Spending an hour listening to Derek didn’t cost me that much, but it led to a few good outcomes. He began accepting the odd visit from the district nurse and engaged with a small number of support hours with one consistent visitor, who he got to know well. Gradually, he began to feel less isolated, and arguably avoided the crisis admission self-neglect can lead to.

So why doesn’t this become the norm in care? Because an hour building trust and getting to know a person is not generally recognised as worth the bother. There’s contact, yes, but the possibility of any sort of relationship never gets going.

Derek, unlike Helder, was already well known to health and social services, having been referred several months earlier. But being ‘known to services’ was not enough to guarantee he got what he needed, and it took a lucky encounter with relational care to ensure he had a fighting chance.

There are several reasons why commissioners do not see the value of relational care. But the main one is that, under the logic of efficiency, funding panels must justify every pound against something measurable. In practice, assessment is narrowed to focus on functional needs, such as whether someone can shower or use the toilet independently. In my experience, broader Care Act duties around wellbeing and prevention rarely make the cut.

In Derek’s case, time-and-task commissioning meant there was no time to notice what he was going through. His needs were then assigned labels such as “non-compliant”, “behaviour that challenges”, “self-neglect” or “declining support”. Often, as I found out, a person not feeling seen or heard is what is actually going on.

For Helder, the sort of care that could recognise his needs earlier generally isn’t there in the first place. The Care Act asks councils to promote wellbeing, prevent or delay need, know what support already exists in their communities, and maintain a healthy market of providers. But commissioning frameworks focus mainly on price and what they can justify in budget terms.

Anything seen as a bit left-field, like a co-op or a neighbourhood care team, is treated as a potential liability in these terms. Partly, I suspect, because getting closer to people can uncover more needs and complications, which in turn can create duties to meet them. These alternative models are given a pilot, short-term funding, then evaluated based on how much they can save the council. And that’s if they’re lucky.

The problem is that relational care is seen as a luxury or an extra, when in practice it is often the precondition for people accepting more formal help. It isn’t some rarefied skill, but without it we can’t ever see a person as whole.

Presence

Luke spent nearly two years trying to build something that might have recognised Helder earlier: an Equal Care Co-op pilot called Clapton Care Commons, run with Hackney and Southwark councils on a grant from the London Office of Technology and Innovation.

Most care organisations see themselves as services — ‘providers’ of care. Even those built on equality and peer relationships still need referrals and end up doing crisis response. The basic premise of Clapton Care Commons was that need and care already exist before outside assessment or intervention is needed. The task was to recognise that and build from it.

So one of the first things to do was map existing caring relationships. Luke’s team started with five people and built support around them: the person at the centre, then family, neighbours, a social worker, local groups, all in one plan. Like a “stacked” care model, the idea was for ‘formal’ (state-arranged and funded support) and ‘informal’ (family, friends, neighbours or community services) support to work together, rather than waiting for one another.

Could this enable the sort of attention missing in Helder’s neighbourhood? In principle, yes. But there was tension between different understandings of the role the councils had to fulfil. Equal Care were trying to build a commons, but the councils, predictably, continued to operate as commissioners: pressure on hourly rates, and treating all providers the same.

Equal Care’s own account described the impasse: “differing protocols, language, and rhythms”. It wasn’t really a partnership. Funding was conditional on “flexibly achieving outcomes”, meaning individual functional gains towards independence, not addressing social isolation or real continuity. Luke told me funds were sometimes withheld on this basis, and for a small business that quickly becomes an issue of survival.

Direct payments for the five people were set at one council’s framework rate rather than what the care actually cost, and one took six months to get in place. A senior council figure dismissed the idea that they should match it as “pie-in-the-sky thinking”.

Ultimately, a circle designed to notice someone like Helder became isolated itself. As Luke said, the councils did not see the model as holding any relevance to their own problems. Equal Care wrote up a service specification of everything they had learned for any council willing to use it. The pilot ended in September 2024 and, as far as I can tell, neither council adopted it. After all, a commons asks a council to do something quite different to what it is used to, or even designed for.

None of which is to say that everything can be reduced to, or solved at, the neighbourhood scale. The list of potential complications is long: trauma, legal duties, cognition, safety, consent, available resources, and a genuine need for privacy are all important. But neglect of something this basic — of human attention — is striking all the same, and it isn’t efficient, even on its own terms.

Loneliness, shame, and loss in all its forms show themselves long before crisis, but only if someone’s there to notice. The official answer is joined-up services: systems working better together at a neighbourhood level. But until systems learn to notice people like Helder, we’ll keep measuring and recording everything except the sort of care that might have made a difference for him.

The publisher is Citizen Network. Living Loss © Thomas Allan 2026.

Article | 16.11.26

community, health & healthcare, Neighbourhood Care, social care, England, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Article

Thomas Allan

England

Contributor

Also see